Beaune Clos De Mouches Blanc (Sep 2004): early signs of oxidation, fading quickly [John Gilman]
Beaune Clos De Mouches Blanc (Apr 2008): not oxidised [Jan-Tore Egge]
Beaune Clos De Mouches Blanc (Oct 2008): not oxidised [Jan-Tore Egge]
Beaune Clos De Mouches Blanc (May 2017): not oxidised [T Duffy]
Chablis Clos (Dec 2003 & Aug 2004): oxidised, undrinkble [David Wästberg]
Chablis Clos (March 2010) not oxidised, no signs of oxidation, incredible wine [Courl]
Chassagne Marquis de Laguiche (Aug 2006): Not oxidized. Ripe, powerful, angular. [Kurt]
Corton Charlemagne (15 Nov 2005): no sign of oxidation, but not great wine [Don Cornwell]
Corton Charlemagne (23 Jan 2008): not oxidized, very nice [Dave Dalluge]
Corton Charlemagne (Feb 2013): 2 bottles purchased on release - not oxidized, powerful and impressive [R Younger]
Montrachet (Sep 2004): early signs of oxidation, fading quickly [John Gilman]
Montrachet (07 Jul 2005): controversial. I detected no overt signs of oxidation, but the color was medium gold (similar to the 96 Leflaive Chevalier on 7/27), rated 93. However, another member of the board at the same tasting (Howard Horwitz) did think the Montrachet was oxidized. [Don Cornwell]
Montrachet (08 Mar 2011): not oxidized. See 95-2000 Retrospective Notes. [Don Cornwell]
Montrachet (Apr 2006) 2 bottles oxidised. [Karl Wee]
Montrachet Marquis de Laguiche (Dec 2009): Perfect cork, great colour and delicious.[Victor Franco]
Montrachet Marquis de Laguiche (Aug 2012): not oxidized [droch]
Montrachet Marquis de Laguiche (Feb 2013): 2 bottles purchased on release - not oxidized [R Younger]
Saint-Aubin 1er Cru (January 2006): Not oxidized, pretty good wine [Frank Drew]