✎ gagnard_jn [Oxidized Burgundies]

This page is read only. You can view the source, but not change it. Ask your administrator if you think this is wrong.
====== Background information ======
\\ 

  * In vintage 1996: no information about batonnage.
  * In vintage 1999: "minimal" amount of batonnage in fear that the wines might become ponderous and lack elegance.
  * In vintage 2003: about the same amount of batonnage as normal
\\ 
====== Wines ======
\\ 
===== 1986 =====

  * **Chassagne Caillerets** (May 2013): not oxidized [MLT]
===== 1993 =====

  * **Chassagne Caillerets** (Nov 2012): not oxidized, but lots of botrytis and unlikely to improve from here [MLT]
===== 1994 =====

  * **Batard Montrachet** (May 2009): fine, no oxidation [MLee]
===== 1995 =====

  * **Chassagne Caillerets** (12 May 2005): (magnum) not oxidized [Don Cornwell]
  * **Chassagne Caillerets** (Jul 2008): not oxidized but mature now, from 0.375 [MLee]
===== 1996 =====

  * **Chassagne Caillerets** (Apr 2005): not oxidized [R DeAngelo]
  * **Chassagne Caillerets** (Dec 2006): definite notes of oxidation... bummer! [Mark A. F. Weiss)
  * **Chassagne Caillerets** (Jan 2008): Oxidized, hideous by second day [Frank Drew]
  * **Chassagne Morgeots** (Apr 2010): both of two oxidized. one slightly and still drinkable. the other completely shot [Stu Jakub]
  * **Chassagne Chenevottes** (Jan 2006): not oxidized, quite youthful [Jim Miller]
  * **Chassagne Caillerets** (2008-2010) six oxidized bottles in a row. A few more left. (A Fenster)
  * **Chassagne Caillerets** (Apr 2013) Fresh and young. A lovely wine. Go figure. (A Fenster)
  * **Batard Montrachet** (Jan 2014): bouquet slightly oxidized, but voluptuous on the mouth. (George Ho)
===== 1999 =====

  * **Batard Montrachet** (Aug 2008) not oxidized, but quite ready [Dale Williams]
  * **Bâtard–Montrachet** (Var. dates 2014 – Aug. 2019): 5 btls not oxidized. Glorious wine, better decanted. From a lot of 6 purchased privately in Hong Kong in Feb. 2014. [Rayner Cheung]
  * **Chassagne Blanchot Dessus** (May 2007): Not oxidized, from .375, excellent, classic [Frank Drew]
  * **Chassagne Blanchot Dessus** (Dec 2012): Not oxidized, but pretty advanced - drink up [MLT]
  * **Chassagne Caillerets** (Dec 2007): Fine, no oxidation at all, from 0.375 [MLee]
\\ 
===== 2000 =====

  * **Chassagne Caillerets** (June 2008): Very fresh, no problem at all [Paul Dellar]
  * **Chassagne Caillerets** (Aug 2008): Just a touch of oxidation, drinkable but drink up, from 0.375 [MLee]
  * **Chassagne Morgeot** (Mar 2010): Oxidized to the point of undrinkable, from 0,375 [M. Døviken]
===== 2001 =====

  * **Chassagne Blanchot Dessus** (Oct 2012): Not oxidized. Decent but not as good as more recent vintages of this wine. [MLT]
  * **Chassagne Blanchot Dessus** (Dec 2012): Not oxidized, needed 1/2 hour decant and then showed very well [MLT]
  * **Chassagne Blanchot Dessus** (Jul 2013): Oxidized, undrinkable [MLT]
  * **Chassagne Blanchot Dessus** (Aug 2013): Oxidized, undrinkable [MLT]
  * **Chassagne Maltroie** (Nov 2007): Not oxidized, excellent, very youthful and structured [BDelancy]
  * **Chassagne Maltroie** (Sept. 2009): Very nice wine in an excellent place right now; not oxidized [H. Cooper]
  * **Chassagne Maltroie** (January 2010): Really nice wine, but much more mature than a few months ago. Not at all oxidized currently, but I would drink remaining bottles [H. Cooper]
  * **Chassagne Caillerets** (Mar 2008): Oxidised, terrible (Al Lacy)
  * **Chassagne Caillerets** (Apr 2008): Not oxidised, perfect (Al Lacy)
  * **Chassagne Caillerets** (July 2008): Another gorgeous bottle celebrating our engagement (A Lacy)
  * **Batard Montrachet** (Oct 2008): fine, no oxidation [MLee]
===== 2002 =====

  * **Batard Montrachet** (Oct 2008): fine, no oxidation [MLee]
\\ 
===== 2004 =====

  * **Chassagne Boudriotte** (Dec 2012): Not oxidized, showed lots of sulphur [MLT]
  * **Chassagne Boudriotte** (Apr 2013): not oxidized but a little underwhelming compared to the quality the Caillerets sometimes attains [MLT]
  * **Chassagne Boudriotte** (Sept 2013): not oxidized [MLT]
  * **Chassagne Boudriotte** (Jul 2014): Oxidized [MLT]
\\ 
===== 2005 =====

  * **Chassagne Morgeot** (December 2008): Elegant and crisp. not oxidized. [Stu Jakub].
  * **Chassagne Caillerets** (August 2012): Not oxidized. [WL].
\\ 
===== 2007 =====

  * **Chassagne Caillerets** (March 2011): Out of half bottle. Not oxidized but badly corked. Will try again but I continue to have issues with JN Gagnard. [Stu Jakub].
  * **Chassagne Caillerets** (Nov 2012, two bottles): Not oxidized; superb. Needs decanting. [MLT]
  * **Chassagne Caillerets** (Mar 2013): Not oxidized, needed about 30 mins of air [MLT]
  * **Chassagne Caillerets** (May 2014): Not oxidized, drinking very well [MLT]
  * **Chassagne–Montrachet "Les Caillerets"** (Oct. 2016 – Feb. 2018): 6 btls not oxidized. Beautiful light gold color. Highly perfumed nose of minerals (inc. talcum powder), most uncharacteristic of this cuvée: my experience, since the 1980's, suggests that the nose should have notes of ginger & ripe orchard fruit. Best served decanted. 6 btls purchased from a reputable West Coast retailer's auction platform in Mar. & Aug. 2015. [Rayner Cheung]
  * **Chassagne Caillerets** (Feb 2019): Magnum, Not oxidized, very ripe floral, banana nose, but finish rather short and flat.  Odd and a bit disappointing for what it is, in magnum (Adrian Latimer)

===== 2008 =====

  * **Chassagne Caillerets** (May 2019): Not oxidized (adrian Latimer)


===== 2009 =====

  * **Batard Montrachet** (Aug 2013):Not oxidized,tight and young [R Younger]
\\ 
===== 2010 =====

  * **Blanchot Dessus** (June, 2017): oxidized ( D Tunnell)
  * **Chasagne–Montrachet "Les Caillerets"** (Jan. 2019 – Nov. 2020): 6 btls not oxidized. Still adolescent, but comes around with decanting or when served in a wide glass. The primary elements still dominate, but there's now (Mar. 2019 – ) good secondary development in the nose & on the palate. From a lot of 6 purchased from the auction platform of a reputable West Coast retailer in May 2016. [Rayner Cheung]